Showing posts with label refugees. Show all posts
Showing posts with label refugees. Show all posts

Wednesday, 13 August 2025

Post No. 3,218 - International conventions, and changing the definition/understanding of refugee/migrant

One of the many devastations caused by World War (part) Two was people being forced to flee their homes for their safety or even their lives. 

In a word, refugees - although today that is limited to hose who have crossed national borders, with “internally displaced person” for those who have not. 

This page suggests the number of displaced people included 65 million in Europe, but there were also millions displaced, including for slave labour, elsewhere in the world, and, after the war ended, there were further displacements as borders changed.  

In 1943 the United Nations Relief and Rehabilitation Administration (UNRRA) * was created to help return people to where they had come from - which is not a simple matter: once the fighting has ceased, the damage has to be undone enough for people to be able to survive, at the very least, and there will be transport, coordination, and identification (to help reunify families as well as weed out war criminals), the changes of borders mentioned above, etc. 

*  The organisation we know today as the United Nations did not exist then: the “United Nations” reference was more to the alliance of nations and intent to do something after the war. See also this brochure about the UNRRA - which later became the International Refugee Organisation in 1946, and helped 10 million out of 15 million “stranded people” in Europe, and then transferred its duties to the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees in the early 1950s.   

In the post war years, the desire for a better world competed with exhaustion, resource limitations, and the new Cold War politics, but an international convention was agreed to provide a management framework for refugees, and that was the “Convention Relating to the Status of Refugees”, which entered into force in 1954, and: 

  • defined a refugee (in Article 1A(2)) as a person who 
    • “owing to well founded fear of being persecuted for reasons of race, religion, nationality, membership of a particular social group or political opinion, is outside the country of his nationality and is unable or, owing to such fear, is unwilling to avail himself of the protection of that country; or who, not having a nationality and being outside the country of his former habitual residence as a result of such events, is unable or, owing to such fear, is unwilling to return to it”;   

and    

  • provided protections including:   non-refoulement,   protection against punishment for irregular arrival (“The Refugee Convention recognises that refugees often need to enter a country without permission, or with false documents, to obtain protection.Under Article 31 of the Convention, countries who have signed the Convention cannot punish refugees for entering or living without permission, or unnecessarily restrict their freedom of movement”),   and   defined their rights, including  the right to a travel document, freedom of religion, the right to work and the right to education. 

Since then, refugees have become a convenient political scapegoat, leading to quite appalling human rights violations for refugees, and nations besmirching their reputations as their hearts & souls wither & die on a thorny bed of fear & lies. 

Despite that, people continue to flee their nations - and not only because of active war, but because of other life threatening circumstances, such as famines, natural disasters, and failed economies. 

A recent newspaper article about that is:   

  • “Despite dangers, migrant flow persists between Horn of Africa and Yemen”   https://www.rfi.fr/en/africa/20250809-despite-dangers-migrant-flow-persists-between-horn-of-africa-and-yemen   “According to the International Organisation of Migration, the route from the Horn of Africa to Yemen is one of the busiest – and deadliest – in the world. Hoping to find work in the oil-rich Gulf states, thousands of Africans, many from Ethiopia, risk their lives on perilous sea journeys. But despite the high number of deaths each year, the route garners less media attention than other migratory flows”       

The other issues that have arisen include various forms of pushback or diversion, which my nation had a significant role in worsening - to its eternal shame (see https://externalizingasylum.info/offshore-processing-in-australia/,   https://asrc.org.au/wp-content/uploads/2013/07/offshore-processing-mythbuster-2012__.pdf,   https://www.unsw.edu.au/content/dam/pdfs/law/kaldor/factsheet/offshoreprocessing.pdf,   https://www.refugeecouncil.org.au/offshore-processing-facts/,   https://www.hrw.org/news/2021/07/15/australia-8-years-abusive-offshore-asylum-processing,   and   https://www.amnesty.org.au/unsafe-offshore-detention-facilities-mean-asylum-seekers-must-be-processed-in-australia/), and forced returns to danger. 

The situation of those forced  back into Afghanistan, especially women and girls, is devastating, but as another example, consider:   

IMO, much of the reason for these regressive or even reactionary changes is due, IMO, to a combination of:   

  • (a) people forgetting what wars and disasters are like;   
  • (c) far right extremist lies and propaganda - which is currently at its worst in the USA.   

 

So ... what to do about this? 

As a first step, the 2018  Global  Compact on Refugees needs to be acknowledged. That agreement aimed to:   

  • Ease the pressures on host countries;   
  • Enhance refugee self-reliance;   
  • Expand access to third-country solutions;   and   
  • Support conditions in countries of origin for return in safety and dignity. 

Unfortunately, it is non-binding, and ran into a world that was hit by the COVID19 pandemic, Russia’s 2022 invasion of Ukraine, and the current insanity and hate in the USA. 

However, the goals are, IMO, the right ones. 

 

Given the binding Convention and non-binding Compact, perhaps the ideal would be:  

  • widespread education of people on both the Convention and the Compact; 
then  
  • prompt (as close to immediate as possible) active countering of the lies - including pursuing each lie as it travels through social media - by official, academic and credible popular sources; 
  • change people’s hearts and minds by:  
    • educating people into seeing the value of refugees and migrants - the USA is currently showing what losing them does to jobs, the economy, lifestyle, etc, but the positive benefits (including to the humanity of the host nation) also need to be “sold” in a way that the marginalised, disenfranchised, and afraid-they’ll-lose-their-social-status will understand and relate to. See  here,  here,  here,  here,  here,  here,  and  here;    
    • continuing that work until there is majority public support for ratifying the “International  Convention on the Protection of the Rights of All Migrant Workers and Members of Their Families”.    

If that was accomplished, it would enable continued use of established systems, but on a more equitable basis ... and it would address the spiritual harm to individuals, groups, and nations caused by being a hater. 

 

However, maybe it is time for a change, a change that would be more difficult, but would ultimately address underlying problems much as wellness budgets better address societal problems than neoliberalism and neoclassical economics. 

And that change would be: 

changing the definition of refugee  


The basis of our existing definition is war - people fleeing for their and their family’s lives. 

It is a minimalist goal - it shares nothing of the global aspiration of the Sustainable  Development  Goals,   it ignores the fact that too many wars are preventable if governments operate with their genuine long term benefit in mind (which would require acknowledgement of things like the residual evil of colonialism, the ongoing evils of white supremacism/racism/misogyny/sexism/other forms of bigotry, and the need for genuine self determination),   and   it condones political skulduggery - especially by undemocratic nations. 

A definition that aligns with human, humane and equitable values such as those in the SDGs would go beyond physical survival to a reasonable quality of life. 

Technically, that is already covered under the existing definitions, but too many politicians across the world (especially authoritarian) have found it convenient to distort what is covered and build up fear and alarm that they can harness for votes. 

Because of that, I am of the view that there is a realistic argument that the battle of trying to fight for the existing definition has already been lost, and thus to gain people’s attention enough to accomplish change, a new line of argument is needed - and hence my concept of expanding the definition of refugee to include quality of life, which in turn would require wealthier nations to accept their responsibility for (a) equitable access to quality of life within their own nation, and (b) equitable access to quality of life globally (see here and here). 

Doing so would require: 

  • a massive popular movement; 
  • a strong commitment to this from enough insiders; or 
  • a combination of both the above.  

If your nation is settled enough (the USA and UK are not - see here for that nations I consider “best”), then an email or similar to your local MP would be a good start, perhaps ... 

Doing the work of this blog on this subject would help, but this is one of those circumstances, IMO, where physical world discussions and spiritual growth as human beings is required above all else. 

 

PS - Marshall  Plan style aid to build the economies of the nations people are leaving would also be of great benefit - including to those providing the aid by building goodwill and a potential market for them ...  

PPS - this shows the depth, extent, and flawed basis of the problem:   “These protests want to 'take our country back'. But the real issues run much deeper”   https://www.sbs.com.au/news/article/these-protests-want-to-take-our-country-back-but-the-real-issues-run-much-deeper/f3jcthbga   “As anti-immigration sentiment rises, experts warn misinformation and fear are fuelling division and distracting from the complex issues at hand”       

PPS - for another perspective on this, see   “Why we need a new playbook for refugee inclusion”   https://www.thenewhumanitarian.org/opinion/2025/08/14/why-we-need-new-playbook-refugee-inclusion   “When refugee communities define who speaks for them and institutions actually listen, we can move beyond the same ‘usual suspects’ and towards policies that reflect justice, not optics.”       



Possible flaws 

Where I can, I will try to highlight possible flaws / issues you should consider: 

  • there may be flawed logical arguments in the above: to find out more about such flaws and thinking generally, I recommend Brendan  Myers’ free online course “Clear and Present Thinking”;  
  • I could be wrong - so keep your thinking caps on, and make up your own minds for yourself.

 

If you appreciated this post, please share it. I am now on SubStack, 
and you can support me at PayPal (or PayPal Repeating Support Options) or Ko-Fi 

 

Remember: we generally need to be more human being rather than human doing, to mind our Mӕgan, and to acknowledge that all misgendering is an act of active transphobia/transmisia that puts trans+ lives at risk & accept that all insistence on the use of “trans” as a descriptor comes with commensurate use of “cis” as a descriptor to prevent “othering” (just as binary gendered [men’s and women’s] sporting teams are either both given the gender descriptor, or neither).

#PsychicABetterWorld   and  

Note that I am cutting back on aspects of my posts - see here, and Gnwmythr is pronounced new-MYTH-ear  

Copyright © Kayleen White 2007-2025     NO AI   I do not consent to any machine learning aka Artificial Intelligence (AI), generative AI, large language model, machine learning, chatbot, or other automated analysis, generative process, or replication program to reproduce, mimic, remix, summarise, or otherwise  replicate any part of this post or other posts on this blog via any means. Typo’s may be inserrted deliberately to demonstrate this is not an AI product.     Otherwise, fair and reasonable use is accepted under Creative Commons 4.0 on an Attribution-ShareAlike basis https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/  




 

Tuesday, 28 July 2015

Post No. 733 - The Battle for the Soul of Australia

I recently did something I don't often do: watch some television. Even more rarely, I actually listened to an ad (mainly because I forgot to mute it), one for an SBS programme called "Go Back to Where You Come From", which aims to educate xenophobic people by showing them the conditions that refugees come from - which suffers from the dual flaws of assuming that all xenophobes (a) have compassion buried somewhere in them, but accessible by the experiences of the programme (I think it is buried much deeper than that), and (b) don't know this already. At any rate, during the ad a xenophobe accuses a whistleblower, someone who had brought out the truth about Australia's abuse of children and other asylum seekers, of being a traitor.

It was all a bit (stereotypical) teenagers squabbling in the schoolyard, as so much TV is, but ... in the sense that the xenophobe - who has been stirring up quite a bit of attention her small-minded self of late - meant, I also am a traitor to "Australia" - specifically, I am a traitor to her xenophobic Australia, an Australia that is so fearful, insecure and small-minded that it has no compassion, hospitality or caring for anyone else. Two of my ancestors were shipped out from Ireland in the early 1800s for "defending their mother's honour against some English soldiers" (i.e., stopping them from raping her), and they were renowned for their hospitality and welcoming of travellers and strangers (including indigenous people). In general, I suspect the Irish traditions of hospitality contributed to the Australians view of ourselves in the 1800s and early 1900s as a welcoming people (flawed though that was, with the notorious White Australia policy that, infamously, contributed to South Africa's apartheid policy), a view still surviving in the view of us as being "neighbourly" .. which is not, and often has not been, true.

The Australia I support is truly generous, welcoming and compassionate - truly "neighbourly", but in a sense that is not focused on the small, one that looks at all humanity (actually, all life) and has room in it's heart to say to the small numbers of refugees who reach us "I acknowledge and am touched by your suffering: let me heal you". The xenophobe is traitor to that Australia.

It all brought to mind a problem I've observed in this battle of late: those who are advocating for refugees know it is important - vital even, and it is: a battle for Australia's soul - but they do not have the eloquence and/or awareness to say that, or to talk of spiritual principles (sadly, those are often either confused for religious principles, or ridiculed). We have no Martin Luther Kings here - or even people who can overcome their emotion enough to come up with a riposte along the lines of the one I just wrote about.

The situation is, ironically, better in the case of the battle for LGBTIQ rights: there, advocates have known that we need to build support by educating people - which was a key part of the reforms I was part of in the late 1990s. There was no focus on marches and demonstrations and numbers, which is a flaw I find too many activists have: there had to be a focus on educating people. Now, both sides think it is a case of big numbers in public demonstrations, whereas it has to be more than that.

Numbers will demonstrate what people think, but that isn't necessarily right. The letter writing campaigns of Amnesty International, for example, are not based on "numbers in the street": they are based on issues, and what is right - and have been remarkably successful.

If numbers in the street were the sole issue, we would not have had anti-discrimination legislation passed in the 1970s.

In the case of recent demonstrations on this issue, as I wrote above, the behaviour has been deplorable, and both sides have been focusing on numbers to put pressure on politicians. The media has been publishing the comments of the xenophobes, but I haven't seen any cogent arguments against xenophobia in the media. I don't know whether that is because the media is choosing not to publish them, or such arguments are not being made, or a combination of those and perhaps other reasons.

In any case, most such arguments are based what is effective for the speaker, not the listener. Arguments about spiritual principles and human rights and human values such as compassion sway me, but they don't sway the xenophobes. If Australia is to become a better nation, arguments on this issue have to be addressed to the listener.

As an example, I know many blue collar xenophobes fear the loss of jobs. When that issue is raised, those advocating for refugees have often been quite glib - e.g., oh they only take jobs few people in Australia want to do anyway. Yes, and it those people who are feeling the threat of competition by people who are desperate enough to accept lesser work conditions. The issue is a valid concern, and needs to be addressed. How about pointing out that many refugees are actually quite educated people, and if Australia was less discriminatory towards such people they would be able to spread throughout the workforce and thus not get forced into competing for jobs that the poorly educated (and that is a reflection on the limited vision of our education system and the politician's who fund it, not the people themselves - for instance, get ridding of tech schools in Victoria was a mistake) find themselves having to compete for.

Then there is the fear over security - sovereignty. Well, leaving aside for the moment the issue of "which Australia?" that I raised above, and the sovereignty of humanity and of life, counter this with facts. Perhaps something along the lines of - with relation to fears around terrorism, for instance - the number of Australian born terrorists vs. the number that come here from overseas, the discrimination and abuse which forces those people into terrorism, the FACT that the majority of refugees are not terrorists, the facts that the majority of people illegally in Australia come in via airports (if that is true - I don't know what the current and recent numbers are), etc.

What about fears of changing the nature of Australian society? Well:
  1. change is inevitable - look at the changes brought about by the Internet and technology advances in recent decades: a better approach is to manage the change, not try to stop it; 
  2. some changes are good - for instance, anti-sexism laws allowing women to keep working after they are married (and the better coffees - initially in Melbourne, but now spreading through the rest of Australia) as a result of the European influx to Australia after World War Part Two; 
  3. some changes are bad, for sure - for instance, the change in Australia away from hospitality towards xenophobia.
What about the view that people should stay where they are - for instance, fight against Da'esh? Well:
  1. I'm still here, fighting the xenophobes; 
  2. that view ignores the reality that people have ALWAYS been mobile - starting with the initial movement out of Africa tens of thousands of years ago, and continuing with the movement of Europeans to Australia over the last few hundred years; 
  3. if I had kids, I also would want to get them out of conflict zones; 
  4. the fact that people want to come here is an acknowledge of the economic advantages (there are depressingly few social advantages nowadays) of Australia, and has to be managed in a way that does not destroy those advantages - which the current xenophobia is doing, by destroying Australia's soul.
In terms of people in Australia turning to terrorism, how about finding out why they do that, rather than making assumptions? A big issue here is that Australia's current predominant lifestyle continues to alienate so many people - and the solution is not to slag off at people about them being party poopers. 

How about countering such arguments with the value of mostly young refugees on Australia's ageing population problem? Or even raise the issue directly of the sort of Australia we want?

I don't consider my arguments to be necessarily good in terms of trying to change xenophobes, but someone has to make an effort on this, so I'll start the ball rolling ... with my very small audience. * SIGH *

This is a battle which has been going on for the last couple of hundred years, beginning with the violent white invasion of Australia, going through the struggles against racism and for worker's rights, the social progressiveness and economic disaster of the Whitlam government in the early 1970s (which helped, as much as the social upheaval of the 1960s, in breaking us out of the "white picket fence" mentality of Australia in the 1950s), the gross materialism and greed of the 1980s, and the politics of fear introduced by the evil John Howard in the 1990s and continued by far too many politicians since then.

It is a battle which needs to be fought and won in every generation - after all, the fight against slavery has been going for several millennia, and against racism for centuries, and they are still going - partly because of the basic them of this post: that activists fail to aim their work at the audience, and also because of denial - thinking that once something has been done (such as the various instruments of anti-discrimination legislation), it does not need to be addressed again. (Mind you, given my utter exhaustion after having been involved in such work, I have sympathy for those who do make the latter mistake.)

It is, at its heart, a battle for spirituality.

I may post more on this topic over time ...

Here are a couple of other links which might be of interest:


[1] BPLF = Balanced Positive (spiritual) Light Forces. See here and here for more on this.
[2] Please see here, here and my post "The Death of Wikipedia" for the reasons I now recommend caution when using Wikipedia. I'm also exploring use of h2g2, although that doesn't appear to be as extensive (h2g2 is intended - rather engagingly - to be the Earth edition of "The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy").
[3] I apologise for the formatting: it seems Blogger is no longer as WYSIWYG as it used to be, and there are a lot of unwanted changes to layout made upon publishing, so I often have to edit it immediately after publishing to get the format as close to what I want as possible.
Love, light, hugs and blessings
Gnwmythr, Pagan Energy Worker, Wéofodthegn
(pronounced "new-MYTH-ear"; ... aka Bellatrix Lux … aka Morinehtar … would-be drýicgan or maga ... )
My "blogiography" (list of all posts and guide as to how to best use this site) is here, and my glossary/index is here.

I started this blog to cover karmic regression-rescue (see here and here), and it grew ... See here for my group mind project, here and here for my "Pagans for Peace" project (and join me for a few minutes at some time between 8 and 11 PM on Sunday, wherever you are, to meditate-clear for peace), and here for my bindrune kit-bag. I also strongly recommend learning how to flame, ground and shield, do alternate nostril breathing, work with colour, and see also here and be flexible.

I am a Walker upon the Path of Balanced Positivity, seeking Spiritual Maturity.
  • Neither eloquence nor inarticulateness inherently indicates correctness, but, as words can kill, the right to freedom of speech comes with a DUTY to be as well-informed, objective and balanced as you can be.
  • Gnwmythr's Stropping Strap: Occam's Razor only works if  the simplest solution is actually recognised as being the simplest, rather than the one that best fits one's bigotries being labelled 'simplest'.
  • I mourn the desecration of the term 'Light Worker' by commercial interests, and the warping of the word 'Light' away from 'Clear Light' by the "(Fluffy) White Lighters".
  • Presuming that everyone has, or wants, a smartphone is discriminatory, unspiritual, and downright stupid.
  • Obsessive love may be a cover up of guilt.
  • Proxy embarrassment is both a form of control, and an internal barrier to truth, honesty and perspicacity.
  • Our entire life experience, with all the many wondrous and varied people, places and events in it, is too small a sample for statistical reliability about Life.
  • Notwithstanding the greatness of exploring the world and humanity, the greatest exploration is of mind, spirit and Soul.
  • May the world of commerce and business be recognised to be a servant, not a master, of the lives of people.
  • Life is not a struggle for status. 
  • Being accustomed to interacting via certain rules makes those rules neither right nor universal.
  • Like fire to the physical, emotions to the soul make a good servant, and a bad master.
  • The means shape the end.
  • My favourite action movie of all time is "Gandhi", although I've recently come across "Invictus" and might put that one in to that category. However, I loathe the stereotypical action movie - and, for similar reasons, I loathe many dramas, which are often emotionally violent, more so in some cases than many war films.
  • All of the above - and this blog - could be wrong, or subject to context, perspective, or state of spiritual evolution ... and blogging has been described as graffiti with punctuation :)
Human dignity is the inherently cumulative holistic combination of human rights, wellbeing and potential, and all actions or interaction which promote, realise or facilitate same. The converse also applies: whatever degrades, diminishes or robs humans of dignity, is inherently undignified.
Gnwmythr
The “purpose” of spiritual evolution is not the attainment of “spiritual perfection” - not in the sense of not having to evolve further, at any rate, since there is no such thing. We need to evolve in order to grow - but we can take rest breaks (hopefully well earned :) ) along the way. No, the “purpose” of evolution is, rather, to perfect our ability to learn, and thus grow.
Gnwmythr
Injustice anywhere is a threat to justice everywhere.
Martin Luther King, Jr.
Females, get over 'cute'. Get competent. Get trained. Get capable. Get over 'cute'. And those of you who are called Patty and Debby and Suzy, get over that. Because we use those names to infantalise females – we keep females in their 'little girl' state by the names we use for them. Get over it. If you want to be taken seriously, get serious.
Jane Elliott
The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good [people] to do nothing.
(based on writing by) Edmund Burke
We didn't inherit the Earth from our ancestors, we only borrowed it from our children
Antoine De Saint-Exupéry
There are risks and costs to a program of action. But they are far less than the long-range risks and costs of comfortable inaction.
John F. Kennedy
Tags:attitudes, change, discrimination, education, racism, refugees, society,
First published: Tysdagr, 28th July, 2015
Last edited (excluding fixing typo's and other minor matters): Tuesday, 28th July, 2015